
Smogon's tiering system has never been the best, but we've dealt with it, however the recent bannings of Excadrill & Thundurus

1. A problem starting...
Towards the end of Gen 4, Smogon made the horrible decision to ban 2 totally OU Pokemon: Garchomp & Salamence, as soon as Garchomp & Salamence were banned, battlers should have left & went somewhere else, however, because Gen 4 was almost over, fans just waited for Gen 5 so they could start over. Little did they know that Gen 5 would be worse, banning garchomp, blaziken,

2. Smogon's Approach...
Smogon's approach to tiering is a ban list: ubers, an uber cannot be used. Some ubers are obvious, like mewtwo,

but others, like balziken, are just stupid. In the past Smogon's found if a pokemon's uber or not by "testing" (mainly voting.) The way a pokemon gets recommend for testing is battlers complain that it's being used to much. Then, the people at Smogon, battle with it for a few days. Then, the people who work at Smogon vote a few times on it, & KA-POW! It's uber! These days, Smogon goes strait to voting, & if a pokemon goes to vote, it's always banned.
Explaining "Uber Mechanics:"
An uber mechanic is a vital piece of the uber metagame, most are pokemon. The most widely known non-pokemon uber mechanic is permaweather, or weather caused by drizzle, drought, snow warning, or sand stream (mostly drizzle & drought.)


However, permaweather isn't banned. Mainly because of it's high use & usefulness, though some people liked speed boost blaziken, the rest of the world decided to ban it (because un-widely used useful things usually are.) This brings me to my solution:
Uber Abilites:
The only way to un-ban uber things that are uber because of their abilities, is to ban thier abilities. If speed boost is banned blaziken would be un-banned, if sand rush was banned, excadrill is un-banned. However, in the case of permaweather teams, pokemon are used for their weather boosting abilities (swift swim, chlorophyll, sand rush, & snow cloak.) This brings the question: "Is permaweather broken, or the abilities they activate?" I'm gonna have to say keep pemaweather, & ban swift swim, chlorophyll, sand rush, & snow cloak. Because if you ban permaweather, people will use the weather inducing moves: rain dance, sunny day, sandstorm, &/or hail (weather inducing moves activate weather for 5 turns, while permaweather never goes away.) Then we'll have the same problem all over again. Permaweather isn't broken.
THE END
No comments:
Post a Comment